Dating site Match.com went live in 1995—it’s ancient in terms of the world wide web. That’s a whole lot of time for users to forget they ever had a profile or what embarrassing content might be on it.

If you buy something from a Verge link, Vox Media may earn a commission. See our ethics statement. On a recent Sunday, creative director Jason Debiak was having breakfast with his family in New Jersey ...

Getting your Trinity Audio player ready... A Match.com profile featuring James Eagan Holmes is genuine, according to a spokesman for the dating website. “There was a profile and it was taken down as ...